Skip to main content

Women's Journal

David H. Peiffer and the Preservation of Evelyn Genevieve Sharp’s Aviation and World War II History in Pennsylvania

David H. Peiffer and the Preservation of Evelyn Genevieve Sharp’s Aviation and World War II History in Pennsylvania
Photo Courtesy: Unsplash.com

Monuments dedicated to the memory of airplane crashes can have a very different function from military campaign memorials and political leaders’ memorials. They can mark specific places, provide information about certain people, and tie a local landscape to a larger historical event. Regarding the history of the Women Air Force Service Pilots (WASP) during World War II, the following facts are pertinent. Between 1942 and 1944, there were 1,074 trained pilots among the WASP, who covered more than 60 million miles without engaging in combat. Thirty-eight of them died. They performed such duties as aircraft ferrying, personnel transport, target towing, aircraft testing, and flight instruction.

Evelyn Genevieve Sharp’s story became connected to this history through a piece of land in New Cumberland, Pennsylvania. After acquiring the property that later became the Peiffer Memorial Arboretum and Nature Preserve, David H. Peiffer learned that an aircraft had crashed there in 1944. The discovery led him to investigate the pilot’s identity and the accident circumstances. Research subsequently connected the site with Sharp, a Nebraska aviator who had already established a career in civilian aviation before joining the wartime ferry program. A 2019 article in Nebraska Life reported that Peiffer located Sharpie: The Life Story of Evelyn Sharp, Nebraska’s Aviatrix, and then contacted its author, aviation historian Diane Bartels.

Sharp’s aviation career began in Nebraska as a teenager. National Park Service records show she began flying lessons at about age 14, completed solo flights at 16, and earned a commercial pilot’s license at 18. She became a flight instructor two years later. At her first teaching assignment in Spearfish, South Dakota, she taught more than 350 men to fly. History Nebraska also records her work as one of the early female airmail pilots and her barnstorming activities before World War II. These details place Sharp’s later military flying within a longer career that had already included commercial aviation, instruction, airmail work, and other forms of civilian flying.

When the United States entered World War II, Sharp became part of the Women’s Auxiliary Ferrying Squadron, or WAFS. She was among the early WAFS pilots and had accumulated nearly 3,000 flight hours by the time she entered the program, according to aviation-history records. The WAFS and the Women’s Flying Training Detachment were combined in 1943 to form the Women Air Force Service Pilots. Sharp’s assignments involved ferrying military aircraft rather than combat operations. Records show that she flew a range of aircraft, including the P-38 Lightning, and rose to squadron commander. By the time of her death, she was only three flights short of the fifth rating, then the highest available to women pilots.

On April 3, 1944, Sharp was killed in Pennsylvania while ferrying a Lockheed P-38 Lightning. History Nebraska and the National Park Service record that the aircraft lost an engine during takeoff and crashed in the New Cumberland area. She was 24 years old. The accident occurred during a ferry flight and became part of the casualty record of the wartime women pilots. The P-38 Association identifies Sharp as the only WASP pilot killed in a P-38 accident. Her death was also part of a larger record of wartime losses among the WASP, with 38 women killed during the program. Sharp was later recognized as a figure in Nebraska aviation history, including induction into the Nebraska Aviation Hall of Fame in 1992.

The connection between Sharp and the Pennsylvania property might have remained largely local had Peiffer not pursued the story after learning about the crash. Bartels became an important source in that research. Her 1996 biography, Sharpie: The Life Story of Evelyn Sharp: Nebraska’s Aviatrix, documented Sharp’s life and aviation career. According to Nebraska Life, Peiffer contacted Bartels after finding the book and discussed plans for a memorial at the crash location. Bartels supplied wording for the memorial plaque and helped seek donations for the project. The collaboration linked research conducted in Nebraska with a physical site in Pennsylvania where Sharp’s career had ended more than seven decades earlier.

A memorial to Sharp was dedicated at the Peiffer Memorial Arboretum and Nature Preserve in 2018. The site contains two elements associated with the crash. One memorial near the entrance includes P-38 propeller blades, while a second marker is positioned near the approximate crash location along the western trail. The crash-site marker is identified by a pile of field stones and an American flag. The propeller blades displayed at the entrance are from a P-38 but are not identified as parts from the aircraft that Sharp was flying when she died. The physical arrangement therefore combines an interpretive memorial with a marker intended to identify the location connected with the 1944 accident.

The memorial also places Sharp’s individual story within the wider history of women who flew for the United States during World War II. The WASPs were civilian pilots during the war and did not receive veteran status until 1977. In 2010, the United States Mint documented the presentation of the Congressional Gold Medal to the WASP, recognizing a group that had flown more than 60 million miles and lost 38 pilots. The Smithsonian records that the women flew numerous types of military aircraft and performed duties that included ferrying, target towing, transport, and instruction. Sharp’s memorial in Pennsylvania therefore concerns a single pilot, but the historical setting extends to a wartime aviation program involving more than 1,000 women.

The Sharp memorial has since been incorporated into the preserve’s public landscape. In 2024, the arboretum’s mountain bike trail was named the Evelyn Sharp Mountain Bike Trail. The preserve’s account states that the trail was developed through cooperation involving The LINK and the West Shore Composite Mountain Bike Team. The route forms a one-mile loop through the arboretum and reaches the area identified with Sharp’s crash site. Cedar Cliff High School students have also used the trail. The result is a route that serves a recreational purpose while passing a site associated with World War II aviation history.

Preserving Sharp’s story fits into a wider pattern in Peiffer’s historical and conservation work, connecting research with physical places and public access. The arboretum itself covers about 35 acres in Lower Allen Township and New Cumberland. It includes nature trails, reconstructed historic structures, and memorial sites. After the 1944 crash was identified, the Sharp project added an aviation history component to that landscape. Through research with Bartels, the 2018 memorial, the crash-site marker, the P-38 display, and the later trail naming, the site now connects a local Pennsylvania location with the documented history of a Nebraska aviator and the World War II WASP program. David H. Peiffer’s work on the subject thus combines historical research with a permanent place of public remembrance.

READ ALSO

This article features branded content from a third party. Opinions in this article do not reflect the opinions and beliefs of Women's Journal.