Women's Journal

Is that “Expert Review” actually a paid lie?

When you want to buy a new phone, sign up for a service, or join an online platform, what is the first thing you do? Most people go to a search engine and type in the name of the product followed by the word “review.” We look for experts because we want to trust someone who knows more than we do.

However, the internet has changed. Today, many of the “Expert Reviews” you find at the top of your search results are not honest opinions. They are advertisements disguised as helpful advice. This is often called “sponsored content” or “affiliate marketing.” To protect your wallet, you need to know how to tell the difference between a real expert and someone who is simply being paid to lie.

The Business of “Review Sites”

To understand why this happens, we have to look at how these websites make money. Running a website is expensive. Many “expert” sites don’t sell products themselves. Instead, they make money through commissions.

When you click a link in a review and buy a product, the website owner gets a small percentage of that sale. This is perfectly legal and very common. The problem starts when the website owner cares more about the commission than the truth. If they tell you a product is bad, you won’t buy it, and they won’t get paid. This creates a strong reason for them to say everything is “perfect” or “the best in the world,” even if it is not.

How to Spot a “Paid Lie”

While some paid reviewers are very good at hiding their intentions, they usually leave clues. Here are the most common signs that a review is not honest:

1. There are No Negatives

Nothing in this world is perfect. Every piece of software has a bug, and every physical product has a small flaw. A real expert will always find something to complain about. If a review only lists positive features and says there are “no downsides,” you should be very suspicious. A real review helps you understand the pros and the cons.

2. The Language is Too Emotional

Real experts use logical, technical language. They talk about facts, data, and their specific experience using the product. Paid reviewers often use “hype” language. They use words like “revolutionary,” “life-changing,” or “guaranteed success.” They want to make you feel excited so that you stop thinking critically and click the “buy” button.

The “Top 10” List Trap

We all love lists. They are easy to read and help us make quick decisions. Scammers and paid reviewers love them too.

Many “Top 10” lists for services like VPNs, online casinos, or web hosting are actually “pay-to-play.” This means the company in the number one spot is not there because they are the best. They are there because they paid the website owner the most money.

To test this, look at five different “Top 10” lists for the same topic. If you see the same unknown company at the top of every list, but you cannot find any real people talking about them on social media, you are likely looking at a paid ranking.

Checking for “Real” Photos and Videos

A real expert will usually show you the product in their own hands. If it is a digital service, they will show you screenshots of the actual interface they used.

Paid lies often use “stock photos.” These are professional photos that anyone can buy online. If all the pictures in a review look like they belong in a glossy magazine and don’t show any “real-life” use, the reviewer probably never even touched the product. They are just repeating what is written on the company’s own sales page.

The “Conflict of Interest” Disclosure

In many countries, it is the law that reviewers must tell you if they are being paid. Look for a small piece of text at the very top or bottom of the page. It might say, “This post contains affiliate links” or “We may receive a commission.”

While having an affiliate link does not always mean the reviewer is lying, it does mean they have a reason to want you to buy. A trustworthy expert will be very honest about this. They might say, “I get a commission if you buy this, but I still think this specific part of the product is weak.” That honesty is a sign of a real expert.

Where to Find the Truth

If you cannot trust the “experts” at the top of the search results, where can you go?

  • Community Forums: Sites like Reddit or specialized hobby forums are great. People there are usually not being paid. They are just enthusiasts who want to help others.
  • YouTube Comments: Sometimes, the video itself is an ad, but the comments section will be full of real users saying, “This didn’t work for me.”
  • Independent Testers: Look for organizations that do not accept advertisements from the companies they review. They are rare, but their advice is worth its weight in gold.

The internet is a wonderful tool, but it requires us to be “digital detectives.” An expert review can be very helpful, but only if it is honest.

Next time you read a glowing report about a new service or product, slow down. Look for the flaws. Check for real photos. Ask yourself, “Is this person helping me, or are they just trying to sell to me?” By staying skeptical, you can avoid the “paid lies” and find the products that actually work for you.

READ ALSO

This article features branded content from a third party. Opinions in this article do not reflect the opinions and beliefs of Women's Journal.